Link to Part 1
During my first year or so of stay-at-home parenting, I went through something of an identity crisis. I had stripped away so many layers of myself until all that was left was “parent” and “stay-at-home Dad”, and beyond those labels I didn’t know who I was. It was embarrassing, and kind of emasculating, primarily because I had no frame of reference for my situation; nothing in my more than three decades of life experience normalized any of it for me. My mom stayed home to raise me. My aunts stayed home to raise my cousins. The men all went out and worked.
In fact, the only stay-at-home Dad I was familiar with was Michael Keaton in Mr. Mom (1983), a film about a man who is laid off from his engineering job at the same time as his wife starts an advertising career, leaving him to take care of their three children. The entire concept of the film is Look at that guy changing diapers, watching soap operas, and making dinner! As is understandable for the time period in which it was released, the situation is depicted as a humorous curiosity, with the expected “Aren’t dirty diapers gross?”/“I accidentally set the kitchen on fire while trying to cook”/”I don’t know how to navigate a supermarket” bits.
Mr. Mom is a cute film that I remember enjoying when I was a little kid. But I can admit that by the time my second relative or acquaintance referred to me as Mr. Mom I wanted to go ballistic. I was getting over the sudden cataclysm that turned my life upside down. I was still processing the loss of my identity and my forced acquisition of a new one that I wasn’t yet sure I was suited to and couldn’t have imagined I’d ever take pride in. I felt embarrassed and inadequate for not being the breadwinner. I felt guilty over denying my wife the ability to be present for all the baby and toddler milestones.
With the guilt came self-recrimination: If I’d just worked a little harder, promoted my business more vigorously than I did, and built a larger regular clientele, we might be sufficiently well-off to afford our own insurance. Then my wife could have stayed home with the baby, or maybe even retired and lived a life of luxury in her late thirties! She would have been the envy of all her friends and relatives!
The thing that eluded me as I fought to escape the morass of cognitive distortions was the fact that I had in fact worked as hard as I could, promoted my business as vigorously as I could, and had as many clients as I could handle. And even if I’d been able to keep that fact in mind, I’m sure the voice in my head would’ve said, “Yeah, but what if you’d worked just a little bit harder?” At that point it was less about logically analyzing my past choices and more about beating myself up for not being what I thought I was supposed to be. It had a major effect on my mental health, though I suspect I’m still not aware of the full extent of it.
In addition to the well-meaning but clueless turds who called me Mr. Mom, I quickly grew disgruntled with the narrow-minded retail clerks who asked if it was “Daddy’s day with the baby” because holy shit, a grown man out in public with a baby? Without the mother present? Should we call CPS right now or wait until the baby loses an eye? I suppose current-day Jack would tell these people to fuck off, or at least express umbrage over their conventional, traditional worldview. But 2010 Jack wasn’t convinced they were wrong to ogle the freakshow.
Oh, footnote to the above: Mr. Mom was written by none other than John Hughes. On the strength of his script, Universal Studios gave him a three-picture deal. Had he not written Mr. Mom, he might never have directed Sixteen Candles (1984), The Breakfast Club (1985), and Weird Science (1985).
Up next: The Good Life to Which I Refer, wherein I realize that I’m actually crushing it and the whole thing probably goes to my head.
Parenting
It [was] a Good Life, Part 1: When My Life Changed
Longtime readers of this blog may recall that I was a stay-at-home Dad for years. Many posts from that era reference the challenges of parenting, especially the difficulty in maintaining an active and adventurous sex life when you’ve got a new baby who never sleeps.
When my daughter was born, I agreed to put my social and professional lives on indefinite hold for the sake of my family. I was afraid that I was ill-suited to the task; prior to my daughter’s birth I’d never changed a diaper and I’d held a baby perhaps fewer than five times. Although my somewhat shaky upbringing wasn’t something I was completely aware of at the time, I knew how high the stakes were that this child be raised to be a functional adult. I knew that if I was going to do this, I couldn’t screw it up.
So yeah, I was afraid. On some level, maybe I didn’t even want to do it. After all, I was self-employed, and giving up day-to-day operation of my business was as scary as leaving my daughter with an unfamiliar babysitter would have been. Beyond that, being a stay-at-home dad required me to give up the home I loved and move hours away, to a much more expensive area with no predetermined living arrangements. In this locale there was no way we’d ever be able to afford to buy or even rent a house comparable to the one we were moving out of.
(The monthly rent on the modest three-bedroom, two-bath house [i.e. smaller than the house we left behind] in a decent but not affluent suburban neighborhood where we lived for a year and a half immediately following the move was just south of $3,000. Compare this to the contemporary national average of $1,083.)
I lamented the imminent loss of my house. The two-car garage. The backyard. The private home office I’d set up for myself in an unused bedroom. The pool table. That’s right, I had a pool table, and I had a room dedicated solely to playing pool while listening to music and sipping top-shelf liquor. Though I’d bought the pool table second-hand, it needed no restoration. Still, I maintained the mahogany and regularly cleaned the rich burgundy felt, and ensured both the sticks and the balls were properly cared for as well. It was the sort of extravagance I eagerly allowed myself as a childless married person, but at this point in my life I can’t even grasp that level of grandeur. It feels otherworldly.
So I had to make an adjustment. Or, more accurately, a series of adjustments. It was a major life change that more than one mental health professional has categorized as “trauma”, even though I’m hesitant to refer to it as such. Hell, my wife and I were going to be living under the same roof for the first time in nearly a year! Sleeping in the same bed! Kissing good night rather than texting good night! There are people who’d kill for that kind of “trauma”, my current self included.
It hurt to lose things I’d worked hard to achieve. Accomplishments that, in my mind, I had no right to ever have expected of myself. These were things I was proud of, things that made me me, and to let go of them or even to step away from them hurt me. I think I eased the pain by telling myself that it was just temporary, that someday we’d be back in the same house (which was being rented out in our absence). This was obviously a lie, and I probably knew that at the time. Still, this was the only way forward. My wife’s job included health benefits and mine did not. She had to work; I had to be the one to raise the kid.
Up next: Mr. Mom, wherein I relive the initial trials and tribulations of that SAHD life.